Fractional COO or a Full Time Hire?
How a nonprofit board can tell whether it needs systems built or systems run
Short answer: hire a fractional COO when the job is to build systems that do not exist yet. Hire a full time COO when the systems exist and someone has to run them every day.
Most boards ask the question backwards. They ask what they can afford. The better question is what the work is. Building has a finish line. Running does not. Pay for the one you actually need.
This edition is for board members and executive directors of nonprofits between $1M and $10M. That is the size where programs have outgrown the back office, and the budget has not caught up.
Hire a builder into a seat that needs a runner, and they leave when the building is done. Hire a runner into a place with no systems, and they spend the first year putting out fires.
WHEN A FRACTIONAL COO FITS
You need a fractional COO when the problem is missing structure, not missing hours.
- Reporting lives in one spreadsheet One person keeps it, and nobody else can rebuild it.
- Compliance lives in someone's head A site review makes the whole team nervous.
- The ED cannot take a week off The place stalls without them.
- Programs grew, the back office did not You added a program or a site in the last two years, and operations stayed the same size.
- The risk is real before the budget is You cannot carry another senior salary yet, but you cannot wait either.
A fractional COO works a set number of days a month. The job is to find the gaps, write the systems, train the people who will own them, and step back. Done right, your staff run the systems without the consultant. Some organizations keep a lighter fractional role after that. For what the role covers week to week, see The Fractional COO Model Explained.
The tradeoff is presence. A fractional COO is not in the building on a Tuesday when a truck breaks down. If you need someone to absorb daily fires, fractional will frustrate everyone.
WHEN A FULL TIME COO FITS
You need a full time COO when the systems are written and the volume to run them is constant.
- Daily senior decisions You run several sites or programs that each need one every day.
- Too many direct reports Three or more managers should report to one operations leader, not to the executive director.
- The SOPs exist People follow them. What is missing is someone to hold the line every day.
- Someone requires it A funder, a merger or a new contract calls for a named operations officer on staff.
- The money lasts You can fund the salary for three years, not one.
The risk with a full time hire is timing. Hire before the systems exist, and your new COO spends the first year on fires with no time to fix the cause.
SIDE BY SIDE
| The job | Fractional: build systems that do not exist | Full time: run systems that do |
| Time | A set number of days a month | Every day |
| Cost | A monthly fee, no benefits | Salary, benefits, recruiting |
| How it ends | When your staff own the systems, or it steps down to a lighter role | It does not; it is a seat |
| Best for | Growth outran the back office | Steady volume across many sites |
| Main risk | Not there for daily fires | Hired before the systems exist |
Many organizations need both, in order. Build first with a fractional COO. Hire full time once the systems are written and the job description is real.
FIVE QUESTIONS FOR THE BOARD
Answer these before you post a job or sign a contract.
- Could a new hire run our core processes from what is written down today? If not, you need building first.
- What breaks if the executive director is gone for two weeks? That list is the scope.
- Is this work building with a finish line, or running that never stops? Be honest.
- Can we fund a senior salary for three years? Not just this one.
- Who on staff will own each system once it is built? If nobody, a consultant will build something that fades.
The question is not what you can afford. It is what the work is.
If you cannot answer question one, start with a look at what exists. The Operations Audit is two weeks, $1,850 flat, every risk ranked by severity, and a 90 day fix plan with a named owner on every line. It tells you whether you need building, running, or both.
This edition is also published in the Run The Mission newsletter on LinkedIn.